I updated to macOS Golden Gate recently, which has had one practical consequence: now in addition to batting away Adobe’s intrusive offers to summarize PDFs or Microsoft’s insistence that I let Copilot create my PowerPoint, I have to also bat away Apple’s little AI icon. It’s not enough to have one “do everything for me” button cluttering my workspace. Now I have to juggle multiple buttons competing for that same privilege. It’s Clippys all the way down.

My students, of course, are inundated with those same “do everything for me” buttons whenever they’re on a device in my classroom. To teach in 2026 is to be acutely aware of this fact. Get even a small group of instructors together today and you start hearing horror stories about classrooms full of zombified students typing their instructor’s discussion questions into an LLM and dutifully reciting what it spits out for participation credit.

Suffice to say, I’ve been leaning much harder in recent years on robust classroom activities—in particular, classroom activities disseminated on paper. Over time, I’ve built up a rough internal rubric of what constitutes a good classroom activity in this age:

  • A good classroom activity delivers information in a manner other than text on a screen. Even if students ultimately translate it back into screen text, there should be friction to that process.
  • It engages students in conceptual and logical thinking, but only after they pass through a layer of sensory experience.
  • It distributes information amongst a group of students, so the only way to complete—or indeed, even fully discern—the task you’ve been given is to speak with your peers.

Pictured above: an example from my Winter 2026 course “A History of Indie Games.”


The week 8 unit of “A History of Indie Games” focused on the tastemaker role played by indie game publishers as the game marketplace has saturated. The week’s two primary case studies—dictated by the readings I was able to find on the subject—were Annapurna Interactive and Devolver Digital.

First, I wanted to frame these publisher’s role within the long history of indie media economics. Entities such as independent record labels, independent film distributors, and now indie game publishers have long used meticulous brand management as a survival tactic, to the point where they become inextricable from a particular style or subgenre. Ask any film critic to describe the concept of “elevated horror,” and you can be sure that they’ll lean heavily on examples from A24’s distribution catalogue. Does “elevated horror” simply mean “a horror movie distributed by A24”? Likewise, where does K Records end the twee pop subgenre begin? Or—to use a hometown Chicago example—how do you conceptualize post-rock without Thrill Jockey, or vice-versa?

So in Tuesday of week 8, I passed out 24 paper strips to my students. Printed on each strip was either a film or a song. Then I set the class loose with the task of finding others like them. They will be stronger together, as a brand! But their boutique brand would be capped at three members. As they made their way throughout the room, they may accumulate, cut, and trade members as they see fit, to reach that magical three. It would be up to each of them to make their best pitch to their peers—playing their song on their phone, showing off the poster for their movies, etc. The activity wouldn’t end until everyone found a home in a three-member boutique brand stable, occupying a unique taste niche.

Once the class formed into their groups of three, I asked the groups: Who are you? What is your company’s name? And how do you define your brand—what stylistic or generic commonality do these works have?

Out of the eight groups that formed, two had mixed-and-matched a bit. As a result, they approached these identity questions as exercises in creativity, making up names for their new companies. But the other six groups had discerned, through their sorting, that this was not a creative task so much as a historical excavation. They had not simply plucked three jangly-sounding indie pop songs from a mass of 24 media objects; they had established K Records. Or New World Pictures. Or Strand Releasing. They had, over the course of about 20 minutes of class time, re-created the particular niche—in terms of both taste and economics—of an actually-existing indie music label or film distribution company.

This Tuesday in-class activity set us up for success in the subsequent Thursday in-class activity. But first, a group gameplay session.


Play sessions for this course all followed the same basic format: I set up four game stations, and students cycled between them in small groups over the course of a three-hour block. Our week 8 session followed that same model, but required additional precision: I needed to ensure that a few students looked at two Devolver games, and a few students looked at two Annapurna games, while the majority of the class looked at one game from each publisher. To facilitate this, I gave each student a “dance card” instructing them to head to a specific station at a specific time. Once again—paper to the rescue!

Thursday’s class was then taken up by one big classroom activity. The students who had looked at two games from a single publisher convened into panels of brand representatives from either Annapurna or Devolver. I asked them to compose a checklist of brand management aesthetic priorities, based on what they had seen during the play session. Everyone else split into groups of 2–3 students and devised a pitch for either Annapurna or Devolver, including details on gameplay, characters, visual art style, and sound design. Then they made their pitches to the brand representative panels, who voted on which game they would publish based on the pitch’s adherence to their aesthetic priorities.

Device use was prevalent during both of these in-class activities. During Tuesday’s activity, students looked up songs on YouTube or Spotify, or scoured the IMDb pages of movies. On Thursday, they made mood boards and art style mockups, sometimes even using generative AI (I didn’t explicitly disallow it). But throughout the process they started from a place of sensory experience, relied on their own human qualities of taste and discernment, and had to constantly navigate their peers while working through the task at hand. There are tweaks I would make if I were to use these two activities again. (For one, both Annapurna and Devolver have had a rough past few years—as has the entire indie publishing business model—so this unit may take on a more “past tense” register if I teach History of Indie Games in the future.) But I’m overall happy with the way they met the pedagogical moment.

Leave a Reply