I first discovered Brander J. Matthews and H.C. Bunner’s short story “The Documents in the Case” (available online here) via David Bordwell’s book Perplexing Plots. Bordwell notes that the story—which consists of a cache of newspaper articles, letters, pawn tickets, and other court evidentiary documents—provoked early 20th-Century debates on the nature and boundaries of literary narration.[i] When I read it, what primarily struck me was how much it resembled what I’ve come to call “evidence box games.”

To draw out this connection, I assigned “The Documents in the Case” in my Spring 2024 course “Narratives of Investigation, Games of Investigation” alongside two digital examples of evidence box games (HER STORY and A Hand with Many Fingers) and two analogue examples (boxes from Hunt a Killer and Unsolved Case Files‘ subscription services).

Each of these games provide players with a raft of evidentiary material, while minimizing or outright withholding a structured to-do list guiding the deductive process. As I was prepping the unit’s lecture, it struck me that the lesson should formally match the material. Perhaps I shouldn’t deliver a lecture at all: instead, I could have students sift through materials and draw their own conclusions sans scaffolding, just as players of these games do.

So I began packing a banker’s box full of stuff. There were 25 students in my class, and each of them would get their own object. First came “mementos” matched to each of the case studies: a pair of pyrite-filled vials for “The Documents in the Case” (prospecting plays a significant role in the story), a broken watch for HER STORY, a red thread for Hand with Many Fingers, a handkerchief from the Hunt a Killer box, an autopsy report from the Unsolved Case Files box. Then there were five red cards blazoned with major concepts: time, conflict, connection, puzzle, redundancy. Beneath each concept was a quote from prior course reading.

To deny myself the temptation of providing additional structure, I sat out the first portion of this class altogether. I asked my friend Omie Hsu to come in and drop off the box in my stead, together with a letter. The letter instructed my students to pair each memento with its corresponding story/game, and then draw a thematic line from the memento to one of the major concepts. Only once they drew the desired connections—verified by inspecting the contents of sealed envelopes, a la Clue—could they move on to the next phase.

During the next phase, attention turned to the remaining 14 students holding 14 additional objects. Some of these were passages of text discussing the definition of narrative, games, databases, and other forms, drawn from figures outside course reading: Aristotle, Hollis Frampton, Lev Manovich, Gonzalo Frasca. Others were images. One student ended up with a QR code that, when scanned, led to an audio file of the piano score that triggers once you’ve found an important clue in HER STORY. My letter asked students to introduce their objects and converse amongst themselves to formulate a question: a central discussion question that tied all of this material together. Once everyone agreed on the question that would form the backbone of the day’s activity, they were allowed to open the final envelope.

The final envelope contained a top-level question: Are “The Documents in the Case” and the other examples successful mystery stories? But it also attempted to anticipate different student approaches. One was definitional: Were any of these “stories” at all, or did they lack too many of the basic definitional elements to qualify? (Narration most obviously, but also techniques of temporal deceleration, or an agreed-upon beginning, middle, and end.) Another had to do with quality: even if we accept that these examples meet the basic definitional requirements of stories, are they actually good mystery yarns? Do they offer the pleasures we seek from the form, such as fair play?

My students didn’t quite get to these exact questions in the end, but it was an invigorating class day nonetheless. It also opened the door to a meta-discussion once I returned to the classroom, with the hiccups in the lesson becoming opportunities to dissect the design challenges of the evidence box form. Although I’ve done other types of concept-mapping in my classes, this this highly tactile and ludic variation stood out to my students. I’d love to return to it again, whenever the material invites such an approach.


[i] David Bordwell, Perplexing Plots: Popular Storytelling and the Poetics of Murder (New York: Columbia University Press, 2023), pg 31. The debates Bordwell mentions occur in the pages of Clayton Hamilton’s book Materials and Methods of Fiction (New York: Doubleday Doran, 1908) and Berg Besenwein’s Writing the Short-Story (New York: Hinds, Noble and Eldridge, 1909).

Leave a Reply